A run dat i(s) Roy
V.K.Saxena
Sigh!
What a run!
From where to where does this woman run! And why? And why does she make us read her marathon passage? Outlook needs to look inwards before they splat her running footprints all over their magazine.
First question to you Ms. Roy. What did you do with your millions that you got from your Booker Prize and the royalty of your book sales apart from building and hiding from public eye your own illegal villa in the notified forest land in MP. Roy pretends to be a campaigner for tribal rights but she is accused of grabbing tribal land in Pachmarhi. And what will you do with the fat cheque you get from writing such long passages in print? Do you disbelieve in capitalism and distribute cash or kind to at least a fraction of the number of poor who pass by your own illegal forest Antilla in torn slippers?
Why do you pretend loving this country? You have breathed sedition in Kashmir, spoken for the naxals, opposed industrial growth, bashed every business house (except the Birlas for some strange reason), established links with ISI agents like Gulab Nabi Fai, who was recently sentenced for two years jail by a U.S court, deposed against national development in UN and international fora with utterly wrong statistics (you are a fiction writer with an award) and criticized everything national. You have even been punished by the Supreme Court for contempt of court.
How credible is your voice? Why don't you suggest any solution to what you perceive as problems? You run criticism and run away from solutions. Do something to prove you are right. Please try and undo what you don't like. At least, bring down the Antilla, break down the dams, tear up the Lokpal bill, stone to death every business leader (except Birlas for reasons only known to you) and take us all to the stone age.
Also build some villas in the notified forest lands for the naxals, if that is your vision and wisdom for the proletariat cause.
V.K.Saxena
President
National Council for Civil Liberties
Ahmedabad - 380 009
web: www.ncclindia.org
e-mail: nccl27@hotmail.com
BLOG: vksaxena-nationfirst.blogspot.com
this a very cheap comment at least the indian bigbusiness could hire some one more decent and intelligent
ReplyDeletethis is the ceap commwent of a police informer a paid agent of the state
agreed Asit. This guy is so pitiful...
DeleteLooks like Narednra Modi is also Promoting their own right-wing civil liberties.
Thanks for your response.Your language clearly shows that you are from the same group who believes that businesses, police and State are people's enemies. Are you operating from the same jungle where your role model Arundati has her illegal villa?
ReplyDeleteIf she has to write, and run, and also provide solutions, then Sir, what will you do?
ReplyDeleteThis is the Modi brand of "Civil Liberties". Sir you are neither "Civil" nor anything to do with "liberty", just a loud-mouth BJP walla.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteExcept capitalism centric modi govt. do u know any thing else better ? How many common trade holders you have killed ? How many weaver families have been destroyed by your mills in the state ?
ReplyDeleteand if she is running, who bars you from running? go ahead and run ahead. you have not been able to answer any of the questions she has raised. and what she does with her own money, is upto her, if you have problems, go to the income tax dept.
ReplyDeleteA writer like Arundathi Roy is exemplary in such she is a writer first and has the right to stste her opinions on any situation or people or ideology she feels like and she does it well. She has done her bit to bring out voices of those who would like to express what she feels but cannot like she does! so why this diatribe against what she believes in and writes about -I enjoy all her writing and as a woman she deserves kudos for raising her voice against establishments and being a critical thinker which is absent in our times hence the sad state of affairs of the world where progress remains just economic and not human-she is the champion of humanity.
ReplyDeleteMr. Saxena .. how come you have forgotten to mention the serious criticisms that has been made on your petition in the Supreme Court...against Medha Patkar? And whose Civil Liberties do you seek to protect ? That of Ambanis and Adanis?? Shame on you.... stooge of Modi, the modern day Nero and Hitler wrapped in one unbearable piece...
ReplyDeleteMr Nitin,
DeleteWhen You have mentioned about the criticisms by Supreme Court than you should know what the Supreme Court has said about your leader Medha Patkar in its judgment dated 11/05/11.
. "The Court has been entertaining this petition under the bona fide belief that NBA was espousing the grievance of inarticulate and illiterate poor farmers, with all sincerity and thus, would not make any misleading statement. However, our belief stands fully belied. Applicant/respondent made pleadings and advanced arguments without any basis only to secure unwarranted benefits to those tenure holders. In the instant case it stands discredited totally in the eyes of this Court. This Court had been a little careful and cautious in this regard, which has exposed the true picture.We reach the inescapable conclusion that the NBA has not acted with a sense of responsibility and so far succeeded in securing favorable orders by misleading the court. Such conduct cannot be approved.
It is desirable that in future the Courts must view any presentation by the NBA with caution and care, insisting on proper pleadings, disclosure of full facts truly and fairly and in case it has any doubt, refuse to entertain the NBA.”
Now you decide who should be ashamed?
Mr Amitabh,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your response.You have actually proved my point.This is what exactly i am telling.If she has the right to do whatever she wants to do with her money, the same rule applies to others also hence she has no business to question every investment in the country.she should peacefully live in her illegal villa.